Way back in high school, I was assigned a project on the classic tome, Moby Dick. I admit, I struggled with it. I realize the novel is highly regarded by many, but to 16-year-old me, it was too long and too boring. I made a valiant effort to read the entire thing, but in the end, I enlisted the help of Cliff (he of Cliff’s Notes fame) to help me complete my paper. And then I did my best to put Ahab, Ishmael, and the white whale behind me.
So imagine my surprise when C. announced that he was borrowing Moby Dick from his 4th-grade teacher and reading it during class free time.
Today, I’m pleased to join the Kids’ Picks carnival hosted by 5 Minutes for Books, by sharing with you an interview C. granted Callapidder Days regarding his reading of this classic Melville novel.
So C., what inspired you to pick up a copy of Moby Dick?
I had heard about it from Mom, and I knew it was a somewhat famous and well-known book, so when I saw it in the back of my classroom, I thought it would be interesting to read that book in my spare time to see what it was about.
Did you have any idea what the book was about before you started it?
I knew that there was a captain of a ship who was pursuing a whale (this whale being Moby Dick), but that was all I knew about it.
Is the book you’re reading the ‘real’ Moby Dick, the one your mom couldn’t get through?
No. It is simplified to a much smaller book, about the size of my hand and it doesn’t have the extra detail that made it (according to Mom) hard to read .
So how many pages does this version have?
I’m not sure how many, but I’m on the 162nd page and from what it looks like on the top, I couldn’t have more than 50 pages left.
210 pages. That’s still impressive. Do you usually read books this long?
My books normally vary from 200 to about 500 pages. My very common books tend to hit in the 300s, so this book is not tremendously, but slightly, short for me.
So, what do you think of Moby Dick so far?
So far, I think it is a very exciting and hard-to-look-up-from kind of book.
Are you serious? What’s so exciting about it?
The basic idea of Ishmael’s trip on the whaling ship is just quite exciting in all that happens.
What do you think of Captain Ahab?
I think that his only concern is to have Moby Dick killed, which is most likely why he’s still in the whaling industry. I think he thinks of himself not as much as the captain of a whaling ship, but rather as an old seaman trying to get revenge on a whale that supposedly “took his life.”
How did the whale take his life?
In his tales of former encounters with Moby Dick, he has said that he will be ruined until he finally gets revenge on Moby Dick. The whale took his leg and caused many other injuries and fate to crew members.
Do you think Ahab will be successful?
Because there is so little to give me a hint on how the story will end, I cannot say for certain, but from what I know about how books usually go, I have a feeling that there is probably a 57% chance that Ahab will not kill Moby Dick and a 43% chance that perhaps he will.
What do you think of the fact that your mom had a rough time getting through Moby Dick when she was in high school and had to use the Cliff’s Notes to help her write her paper?
I think that, for that copy (the one she had to read), Cliff’s Notes could come in handy, but I’m enjoying this rather simplified copy. It’s much easier to read and if I happen to have a chance to pick up Cliff’s Notes, I don’t think I’ll have a need to.
Are you interested in reading more classics like Moby Dick in the future?
Well, yes. I like reading classic books that I’ve heard about and think would be interesting.
What book is next for you?
At school, I have been reading Moby Dick, but at home, I’m reading The Mysterious Benedict Society and the Perilous Voyage (not a whaling voyage, mind you), but my next book at home will probably be Around the World in 80 Days, a book that I got a while ago and have not yet read. It is another classic, a hardcover, from the same publishers that made the version of Moby Dick that I’m reading.
Thank you, C.. We appreciate your time and your willingness to share your thoughts with us.
Editor’s Note: C. has read one other “simplified” classic recently: War of the Worlds. These are all books from the “Great Illustrated Classics” series. While kind of pricey on Amazon.com, I’ve found these books for just a couple dollars at Michael’s craft stores. I think they do a good job making some classic books accessible to a younger set of readers.







{ 15 comments… read them below or add one }
Awesome job, C.! Not many kids your age can say they’ve read Moby Dick. And now you don’t have to wade through that looooooong version that your mom and the rest of us tried to get through. I didn’t use Cliff’s Notes but must admit I “skimmed” a couple of the more encyclopedic chapters — the ones on everything anyone could possibly, ever, want to know about whale blubber
Oh C. – you make my heart sing!! I LOVED Moby Dick in high school. (and was sorely hated by my classmates for doing so!) The detail was a little overkill (I think they may have gotten paid by the word back then) but it was worth wading through to follow Ahab in pursuit of Moby Dick. Thank you for doing this interview and I hope you inspire many other kids to tackle these classics!
Bravo for C.! I have to admit I never got through this one either, and I was an English major.
I did read a couple of Melville’s stories, but that’s about it.
Yay for C.! You’ve got quite the reader on your hands I do believe.
I don’t think I’ve ever read that one either. I think I’ve seen those small books, great illustrated classics…sounds like a good thing.
Cute new digs you’ve got, guess you got the kinks worked out!
Wow! I’m way impressed! That was a great review. Thanks, C., for your time!
This interview was too funny! Moby Dick was awful. I read it as an adult. So much of the story was unneccessary.
Great post! You’ve got a smart little guy there, but I’m sure you know that.
I read Moby Dick in high school and I believe I was good friends with Cliff as well.
That’s great that he chose a classic! I have to agree that I didn’t like the book that much in high school. Thankfully our teacher only made us read excerpts that were essential to the plot (about 2/3 of the book). Even at that our teacher was like the monotone teacher on Ferris Bueller, so it wasn’t hard for him to make it boring.
Well done C.!!! Love your new blog look too!
LOL!! 57% chance…so C..
I need to check out those Great Illustrated Classics. Nick wants to read Robinson Crusoe…but the version written in the 1700s is too much for him…even with us reading it together. We have to stop alot and explain words and phrases that he doesn’t understand..okay, maybe 6 years old is too young, but he wants to read it.
Well, now I feel like I need to go and pick this book up. I’ve never read it. How sad is that?
And I laughed at the 57% vs 43%…
Pretty good for a 4th grader!
cjh
I always see those at Michael’s, too, and occasionally at the dollar store!
I like this interview. Did he really say “Tremendously?”
And I missed out reading Moby Dick in high school, because it was the 150th anniversary of the Constitution or something like that, so instead we wrote research papers (which I didn’t mind) and read the Federalist papers, which I don’t think I really read either.
I remember reading Little Woman and Heida in this version as a little girl. I have never attempted Moby Dick. I want to. It is on my to do before I die list.
Wow, I didn’t know there were such things as “simplified classics”! My kiddo would LOVE these – they’d be perfect for our read-together books (he’s in 1st grade so I’m doing the “reading” part, he’s doing the “together” part). Thanks!
Great job C.!
Sad story from my childhood: When I was in 2nd grade I decided I wanted to read Moby Dick. When our class went down for library time, I asked the librarian where I could find it. She said the highschool would probably have a copy of it – she’d pick it up and have it waiting for me next week. I was so excited all week! I did a happy dance all the way down the hall to the library when the day finally arrived. I went bouncing up to the librarian in glee. She looked at me and said, “I found the book. It’s too hard for you so I didn’t bring it.” Period. That was it. I was so upset. I vowed that I would find it and read it on my own. But I never did…
In college I came across Moby Dick and bought it on the spot, just to spite my elementary school librarian. I’ve still never read it. But after reading your review, maybe I’ll just have to go get it now…
Again, great review!
Z-Dad
{ 1 trackback }